The Commoner

Did You Think It Was Going to Be Easy?

Bitcoin fell below $62,000 on Coinbase over the weekend. The network kept producing blocks, and Check's transfer-value chart gives us something worth looking at beyond the price.

10 min read
Did You Think It Was Going to Be Easy?
Share
TFTC - Truth for the Commoner

The Commoner

Monday, November 16, 2026


Sup, freaks.

A brutal week for bitcoin holders does not make the monetary system we're trying to leave any more trustworthy. I want to spend some time on what we're actually here to build.

WHAT TO EXPECT IN THIS NEWSLETTER

  • The bitcoin selloff, last week's liquidations and Check's transfer-value chart.
  • Corallo on Stratum V2 progress and who gets to choose the transactions in a block.
  • Malthus on postponing marriage, and the memecoin windfall behind AI-policy advocacy.
  • Logan wants weekend discount-window access; San Diego weighs Flock's future.
  • Specter Desktop makes wallet labels portable.

Marty's Bent

Did You Think It Was Going to Be Easy?

Did you think it was going to be easy?

That's what I asked on Rabbit Hole Recap in the clip we put out yesterday, and I think it's worth asking again after the weekend we just had. We're attempting to bring a separate monetary system to the masses. One that allows individuals to hold their own money and transact with each other without depending on a central bank or a trusted intermediary. Did we really expect that process to be a comfortable ride up and to the right?

When we recorded the conversation with James Check that came out Saturday, bitcoin was hanging around $72,000. By Sunday it had traded as low as $61,946 on Coinbase. At this morning's snapshot it was back around $64,500. A lot of leveraged longs got absolutely smoked along the way. Liqwall puts bitcoin long-position liquidation notional at roughly $1.78 billion over November 9 through 15. Add a strengthening dollar and the uncertainty hanging over markets and you can see why people are feeling pretty miserable right now. It feels to me like we may be finding a bottom, though we'll have to see how that plays out.

What I keep coming back to is the fact that the governments and central banks we're trying to separate our money from haven't materially changed their ways. I expect them to lean harder on the same policies as the pressure builds. I don't see trust between the world's superpowers improving either. In that world, the ability to save and transact using a monetary system that doesn't belong to any one of them seems incredibly valuable to me. Even if the market isn't expressing that value in the price at the moment.

Saifedean gets to the heart of this in a recent exchange. Who decided that we should all depend on central banks in the first place? He pushes back on the idea that society voluntarily chose this arrangement and argues that the central-bank backstop protects banks from the consequences of expanding credit. His opponent sees public institutions as a way to provide for collective needs. I'd rather individuals have the ability to decide for themselves. With bitcoin, they can opt into a monetary system that doesn't require them to trust those institutions with their savings.

And that option remained available throughout the selloff. Blocks kept getting produced. Individuals could still run the software, verify the bitcoin they were receiving and send it to someone else. The network continued doing what it was built to do while leveraged positions were getting liquidated around it.

Check pointed to roughly $10 billion a day in bitcoin transfer value during our conversation. His chart's 30-day average climbed from $8.34 billion on October 11 to $9.98 billion on November 11, before easing to $9.57 billion on November 15. A considerable amount of value moving across this network every day, even as the price makes it hard for people to get excited about it.

Checkonchain chart of bitcoin USD transfer volume with 30-day and 365-day moving averages

Source: Checkonchain, Transfer Volume Momentum. USD transfer value, with 30-day and 365-day averages. The 30-day average was $9.57 billion on November 15.

I don't think bitcoin's fundamentals have ever been stronger, and I can't remember a time when the narratives that explain why this thing matters were getting less attention. We can hold our own money and transact without asking permission, yet those abilities seem to get lost in the conversation when the price is falling.

What I'm curious to see is which external events or developments bring those ideas back into the mainstream conversation. If more people find themselves questioning who controls their money or whether they can trust the institutions holding it, we should be able to explain why bitcoin is useful to them. Keep an eye out for it, freaks.


Sponsored
Braiins Hashpower: 1,000 Mini Miners for 10,000 sats

🎰 1,000 Miners For 10,000 Sats

The cheapest solo package on Braiins Hashpower gives you the hashrate of 1,000 Mini Miners for a few hours. No configs, no waiting. One click and you're hunting for a block.

BUY HASHRATE

SIGNAL

Bitcoin Mining

Stratum V2 is moving. Template control is the next step.

Matt Corallo highlighted a useful week for Stratum V2: Foundry announced testing, MARA mined a block using it according to Corallo, and Luxor announced support. These are encouraging signs that better mining infrastructure is making its way into the big operations.

The distinction in his thread is important. Sv2 can improve the security of communications while a pool still chooses the transactions its miners work on. Giving miners that choice requires the separate Job Declaration protocol. Corallo also points to P2PoolV2's beta activity on testnet5. The question I want to keep following is how much of this progress reaches the point where individual miners are choosing their own block templates. Getting the transport in place gives them something to build on.


Family Formation

Waiting until you can afford a family is an old argument

Vittorio surfaced a passage from Malthus about people delaying marriage to preserve the comforts they already enjoyed. In the 1798 essay, Malthus describes men in the highest ranks delaying marriage because of expenses they would have to cut and pleasures they would have to give up, then follows the calculation down the income ladder, where the constraints become more substantial.

There is something worth sitting with here. Providing for a family requires real resources. It is also possible to keep moving the definition of enough until the decision never gets made. Better money would make saving for a family easier. It would not make every tradeoff disappear, or decide for us which comforts are worth giving up to have children.


AI Policy

A memecoin windfall behind AI-policy advocacy

BPI traced a consequential funding story: Vitalik Buterin's 2021 SHIB donation helped finance the Future of Life Institute. Its tax filing recorded $665.9 million in noncash SHIB. Buterin says FLI converted it into roughly $500 million. BPI's $51 billion headline appears to use fully diluted SHIB valuation, not the donation's value.

FLI later organized the 2023 letter calling for a pause of at least six months on training systems more powerful than GPT-4. Buterin has criticized its political turn while praising some recent initiatives. FLI says his gift was unconditional and he has no decision-making role. BPI reports no evidence of illegal or unethical conduct by FLI. The funding still deserves scrutiny: a memecoin windfall gave an organization substantial resources to advocate restrictions on what other people can build.


Federal Reserve

Logan wants the discount window open on weekends

Dallas Fed President Lorie Logan argued Friday that the Fed should extend discount-window operations to weekends and holidays. Instant-payment services can create funding needs on days when banks cannot borrow from the window. Banks need their collateral, paperwork and procedures ready, and Logan wants the Fed ready on its side too.

This remains a recommendation requiring action beyond one Reserve Bank. Logan also said Treasury markets are functioning well and argued for more restrictive monetary policy. What caught my attention is the operating mismatch: payments can move on a weekend while the central bank's ordinary lending window is shut. The institutions promising faster money still have to work out who supplies liquidity when their old schedule gets in the way.


Surveillance

San Diego's mayor will not veto a decision to end Flock

San Diego Mayor Todd Gloria says he will not veto a council decision to end the city's Flock license-plate-reader program. In his Friday statement, he acknowledged that Flock and the city's use of the technology have lost public trust.

The council is scheduled to consider continued authorization this afternoon, with discussion items beginning at 2 p.m. Pacific. That decision was still pending when this issue was prepared. A system that records where people's cars travel deserves more than assurances from the people running it. The mayor's commitment gives the council room to say no. Now residents get to see what their representatives do with it.

Sponsored

Cash App

Cash App lets users buy, earn, send and spend bitcoin.

Cash App's TFTC offer page currently advertises a $21 referral bonus for eligible new U.S. customers using code TFTC10. The offer requires a qualifying payment of at least $5 within 14 days; account-linking and other eligibility conditions apply. Review the offer and terms before signing up. Bitcoin services by Block, Inc. See the Bitcoin disclosures at cash.app/legal/podcast.

#blockpartner

Disclaimer: This newsletter is sponsored by Bitcoin at Block, including Cash App, Square, and Bitkey. Disclosure: Bitcoin services are provided by Block, Inc. Bitcoin services are not licensable activity in all U.S. states and territories, and not all services are available in all states. Bitkey is not available in New York. Block, Inc. operates in New York as Block of Delaware and is licensed to engage in virtual currency business activity by the New York State Department of Financial Services. Bitcoin is a non-deposit, non-bank product that is not FDIC insured and involves risk, including monetary loss. For additional information, see the Bitcoin disclosures.

Get Cash App

⚡ FREEDOM TECH CORNER

Take your wallet labels with you

Specter Desktop v2.3.0 adds BIP-329 label import and export. If you've put time into annotating your wallet, a standard export format gives you a way to carry that work into other compatible software instead of retyping it. The release also improves Specter-DIY key imports and adds a Taproot support flag for BitBox02.

Before upgrading or changing the installation backend, use Settings → Backup Specter to create the backup ZIP the maintainers recommend. Keep that file private: wallet labels can reveal information about your transactions. Check the platform notes before downloading. This release has no Windows GUI installer, although a Windows daemon is included; the macOS application is not Apple code-signed or notarized. Start with the release notes and verification files, not an unsolicited download link.


DATA SNAPSHOT

Spot quote, block height and hashrate retrieved November 16, 2026, about 10:47:30 AM EST (15:47:30 UTC). Bitcoin Lab daily observations: November 15, 2026. ETF flows: November 13, 2026, latest available at retrieval.

Bitcoin Price$64,540.00
Sats per Dollar1,549
Block Height976,146
Network Hashrate965.6 EH/s
Total Fees (Daily)$139,228
MVRV Ratio1.21
MVRV Z-Score0.38
STH SOPR0.967
STH Realized Price$74,653
Realized Price$53,723
NUPL0.176
Realized Cap$1.080T
US Spot ETF Net Flow-$185.5M (November 13; latest available)

Kraken spot quote, mempool.space, Bitcoin Lab, TFTC ETF flows.

From TFTC

We're taking three businesses

Over the last few months we've worked with a comedy club, a real estate agent and another media company to rebuild how they operate with AI agents, and the results have been massive. Now we're opening it up. We'll work hands on with business owners to transform their business with AI agents in three months, and we're only taking three in this first round.

If you run a business and know you should be implementing AI but don't know where to start, or you feel like you're underutilizing it and don't have the bandwidth to fix that, apply below. It's how we'll pick the three.

Apply for one of three spots

TFTC Roundtable

Serious bitcoiners and operators are building leverage with bitcoin, AI, energy, and company-brain workflows inside the Roundtable.

Join the Roundtable

Plug your agent into TFTC

TFTC runs a free, read-only MCP server. Connect it to Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor, Hermes or another compatible MCP app, and your agent can search The Commoner and TFTC podcast transcripts and retrieve the latest available spot ETF flows and Treasury auction data, with source links included in the returned results. No TFTC sign-in or API key required.

Connect your agent

⚡ Want to find products and services built for bitcoiners?
Browse BitcoinProducts.com

Have a great week, freaks.

Marty Bent · TFTC · Nostr

YouTube

Podcast

News and analysis, not financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Figures and quotes are verified against primary sources where possible. See our editorial and financial disclosures.

Keep reading

All of TFTC
Fear Malware
The Commoner

Fear Malware

Walter Kirn’s Brownstone remarks hit home. I was shopping for generators before the midterms. It is time to reclaim the attention…

The Commoner

Truth for the Commoner, every weekday. Money, machines, and the people trying to control both.

Independent writing by Marty Bent at TFTC since 2017. Money, markets, AI, energy and privacy, delivered free to your inbox.

Free, every weekday. Unsubscribe anytime using the link in each newsletter. By subscribing you agree to our Terms and acknowledge our Privacy Policy. Read recent issues.