Economics

VanEck Drops Gemini From All Three Crypto ETFs, Coinbase Takes Sole Custody

VanEck terminated Gemini's custodial and clearing agreements across all three of its crypto ETFs on November 16, 2026, with no public explanation. Coinbase Custody consolidates as the remaining custodian. VSOL's staking provider is unresolved.

3 min read
A steel bank vault door, its massive locking bolts partially retracted, stands slightly ajar in a dim concrete corridor, the cold blue-white glow of fluorescent overhead lighting casting
Share

VanEck served Gemini termination notices across HODL, ETHV, and VSOL simultaneously, with no explanation. The who-holds-your-bitcoin question just got less comfortable.

Key takeaways

  • VanEck delivered written termination notices to Gemini on November 16, 2026, covering custody and clearing agreements for all three funds (HODL, ETHV, VSOL), effective February 16, 2027, per three SEC 8-K filings.
  • Coinbase Custody consolidates as the sole remaining custodian. For HODL, Gemini was the primary bitcoin custodian and Coinbase was listed as the additional custodian. That hierarchy flips entirely in roughly 90 days.
  • For VSOL, Gemini's staking services addendum terminates alongside custody, and VanEck has not named a replacement staking provider.

VanEck Digital Assets, LLC served written termination notices to Gemini Trust Company, LLC on November 16, 2026, ending custody and clearing agreements across the VanEck Bitcoin ETF (HODL), the VanEck Ethereum ETF (ETHV), and the VanEck Solana ETF (VSOL), per three separate 8-K filings submitted to the SEC on November 19: HODL, ETHV, and VSOL. The terminations are effective on or about February 16, 2027. No reason was given in any of the three filings.

Coinbase Custody Trust Company, LLC remains as custodian for all three funds. Gemini will continue providing services under all existing agreements until the termination date.

What the Filings Actually Say

Each 8-K terminates two separate contracts: the Custodial Services Agreement and the Gemini Clearing Agreement. For HODL, those agreements dated to October 2023. For ETHV, custody dated to May 2024. For VSOL, the custody agreement dated to June 2025, the most recently signed of the three.

The VSOL filing adds one more item: Gemini's staking services addendum terminates with the custody agreement. VanEck has not named a replacement staking provider, leaving an open operational question for VSOL holders. The ETHV filing raises no equivalent issue. Neither VanEck nor Gemini responded to requests for comment as of publication. CoinDesk first reported the story.

The 8-Ks do not disclose how much of each fund's assets Gemini currently held, nor do they identify any exit fees or penalties.

The Custody Concentration Problem

The HODL angle is what matters here. For the VanEck Bitcoin ETF, Gemini was the primary bitcoin custodian. Coinbase was listed as the additional bitcoin custodian in prior filings. After February 16, 2027, all custody of HODL's bitcoin flows through one counterparty.

That is not necessarily more dangerous than the prior arrangement. But it does remove redundancy. The concentration hasn't shrunk. It has just moved.

The more uncomfortable signal is the silence. Companies that make routine, fee-driven custodian consolidations typically say so. A brief explanatory line in an 8-K costs nothing and defuses concern. VanEck offered nothing.

When a tier-1 ETF issuer simultaneously pulls a counterparty from every product it runs, three weeks before year-end, and gives that counterparty roughly 90 days' notice with zero public explanation, the most honest read is that the issuer's risk team made a verdict, not a scheduling decision. The Gemini consent order history is relevant context here.

For a sharper frame on how institutional bitcoin custody actually functions behind these wrappers, the TFTC conversation with Baron Koch covered the gap between what ETF investors are told and what the custody stack looks like in practice. The Datavault episode also illustrates what happens when bitcoin gets frozen at a third-party custodian with no recourse for holders.

What to Watch

The practical question for HODL shareholders is whether Coinbase Custody runs the full transfer before February 16 and whether VanEck files any subsequent 8-K clarifying the reason for termination.

For VSOL holders, the staking question is unresolved and directly affects yield. Watch for a Form 8-K amendment or a prospectus update naming a replacement staking provider. If VanEck stays silent and Gemini simultaneously wins a comparable new institutional custody mandate from another ETF issuer within the next 90 days, the risk-management read of this termination weakens considerably. Until then, Gemini's standing in the institutional custody stack has a question mark next to it that VanEck put there.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did VanEck drop Gemini as custodian?

The three SEC 8-K filings do not state a reason. Neither VanEck nor Gemini has commented publicly. The simultaneous termination across all three funds, with no accompanying explanation, is the entire public record as of now.

Is bitcoin in HODL at risk after Gemini is removed?

Coinbase Custody Trust Company remains as custodian and will hold all of HODL's bitcoin after the transition. Gemini continues providing services under existing agreements until February 16, 2027. The transition removes the redundancy of a two-custodian structure and consolidates everything with Coinbase, but no immediate disruption to HODL's holdings is indicated by the filings.

Who is handling staking for VanEck's Solana ETF after Gemini exits?

The VSOL 8-K confirms that Gemini's staking services addendum terminates alongside the custody agreement. VanEck has not named a replacement staking provider. This remains an unresolved operational question that will affect VSOL's yield profile.

News and analysis, not financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Figures and quotes are verified against primary sources where possible. See our editorial and financial disclosures.

Keep reading

All of TFTC

The Commoner

Truth for the Commoner, every weekday. Money, machines, and the people trying to control both.

Independent writing by Marty Bent at TFTC since 2017. Money, markets, AI, energy and privacy, delivered free to your inbox.

Free, every weekday. Unsubscribe anytime using the link in each newsletter. By subscribing you agree to our Terms and acknowledge our Privacy Policy. Read recent issues.