Théo Mogenet: The Debt Trap Has No Exit Transcript — TFTC Article: https://www.tftc.io/financial-repression-debt-trap-bitcoin-self-custody-theo-mogenet Transcript page: https://www.tftc.io/financial-repression-debt-trap-bitcoin-self-custody-theo-mogenet-transcript Published: 2026-11-21 Machine transcription, lightly cleaned; may contain errors. ======================================================================== [0:36] Marty Bent: Theo Mojanay, welcome back to the show, sir. It's been a long time. [0:40] Théo Mogenet: Thanks for having me, Marty. Indeed. [0:43] Marty Bent: I mean, the last time you were on, we were talking about what? Bitcoin money market funds. [0:46] Théo Mogenet: Exactly. [0:48] Marty Bent: Yeah. And it's been a long time. A lot has passed. You've joined Bull Bitcoin since we last spoke, and you guys are putting out a blog series that started with a manifesto called The Cost of Lies. I think everybody should go read it. Number one, we'll link to it in the show notes, but I just reread the manifesto and the most recent piece on France titled— what's the title of this? Laissez-nous faire. That I think is really important, particularly right now, and particularly for Bitcoiners, because it feels like we're somewhat wandering in the wilderness here in the bear market. It feels like the sentiment is lower than it's ever been, and one of my bigger focuses in the newsletter and more recently on the show is trying to get people back to first principles. [2:03] Théo Mogenet: First, because I got Francis to pay my salary for returns, for writing stuff that I wanted to write for a long time. You know, this type of newsletter takes a lot of time, especially if you try to write them mostly without using AI. I think it's also really enjoyable for folks to read well-thought-out and well-written pieces in this age of AI slop. I have a kind of AI slop fatigue myself. So, and Francis too, even worse, I would say, than mine. And so yeah, I think it was a good endeavor. And as you mentioned, we can witness in our friends, family, sometimes clients, that a lot of people, especially in the last cycle, have been drawn to Bitcoin for like sailorism, price action, and they have a hard time focusing on the ball and understanding that the path towards Bitcoin being like the main form of capital or money in the world is extremely volatile and it will knock out a lot of legacy systems along the way, which makes it really logical that you kind of get this type of really volatile price action. [4:03] Marty Bent: Yeah, and so let's let's jump into it. I love the the titles of the first two pieces of the manifesto: The Cost of Lies and then Laissez-nous faire. But I think really setting this up and again grounding people in first principles: Why are we here? Why do we Bitcoin? Bitcoin is was launched as a reaction to the unfettered sort of debasement of currencies that. central banks and governments have proven to revert to when, when times get tough. And I think the manifesto setting up the lie and really tying it to Chernobyl in the beginning is important that, that we're basically selling each other lies in the monetary system. Most people don't realize this. [4:52] Théo Mogenet: Yeah, I use that as an introduction because I watched the HBO series about retelling the Chernobyl accident. And at the end of the series, you have this scene where the scientist, nuclear scientist leading the state response, is asked to testify at the trial of the operators of the reactor. And he's asked how such a nuclear reactor could explode, because it's not supposed— To be a nuclear bomb, it's a really different physical system, and it's not supposed in its design to behave that way. And of course, the USSR being the USSR, they wanted to pin the error on humans because the one thing you can't do in the USSR is saying our system is defective. [8:47] Marty Bent: Yeah. And that's, that's again, I really want the theme of this to be like grounding in first principles. Why are we here? And I think that's one thing that myself is— I'm guilty of myself is, is getting disillusioned and forgetting about the math behind all this. And so to your point about the comparing this to the Chernobyl incident, you have it in here. The RBMK reactor had a positive void coefficient. The more its cooling water boiled into steam, And the more reactive the core became, the hotter it ran and the more water boiled. So you create this sort of negative feedback loop. And that is a— it's a problem of physics with the steam reactors. [10:01] Théo Mogenet: Yeah, I think it's an interesting way to look at this because mathematics in finance and in economics at large have always been linear mathematics, I would say, because the mathematical education of people getting a PhD in economics or people getting an MBA, such as myself, are not on par with nuclear scientists, for example. But when you delve in this type of math that are full of feedback loops, as you mentioned, so causes retroacting over themselves, you are better equipped to understand these second-order effects and this chain reaction that can appear. One example I give in the piece is that the economic theory holds that if you raise interest rates, you are supposed to get less money printing because it should curb the ability of banks to extend new credits, and it should also curb the ability of the governments to increase deficits. [13:28] Marty Bent: Yeah. And as it pertains to like the debt situation, deficits on the side of governments, I mean, this gets exacerbated when you have the nanny state offering welfare. And I think that was the focus of your most recent piece on France, which we'll dive into. But I think really highlighting to your point, like the theory may say, here's how things should work if we do these things. But the reality of the situation is such that theory doesn't compute because I think the welfare state globally has grown too large. And so you can't cut a lot of the spending that is necessary to bring down the overall debt burden. [15:05] Théo Mogenet: If we lay out the problem in the simplest way possible, I think is that if you define it's an abstraction, don't consider that this is something that really exists. But if you define like R as the average interest rate across the debt securities issued by your government and G the average growth rate of your economy, in theory, your tax receipt should increase as a linear function of the growth rate because we just have the same interest, like tax rates levied on bigger flows. Whereas then the difference between these 2 quantities, G and R, times the size of the stock of debts as a percentage of GDP, should tell you what is the size of the flow that is gobbled up every period, every year, let's say, just for the interest expense. [27:19] Marty Bent: Yeah. And they can spin a narrative too. Like, oh, we need to do this national security. We're packing it in. Can't move your money outside the borders. Do your part. Buy the war bonds. [27:29] Théo Mogenet: And in many cases, they don't even need to at the beginning because people are not aware of it, because the financial system is so complicated that when, for example, the Trump administration will say, okay, I like stablecoins, but I want you guys to back the stablecoin by short-dated government securities. I don't think that the millions of stablecoin holders in the world are really understanding that they are financing the operation of the US government, the war in Iran, or the welfare systems in the US or whatever. It's something that is really silent. At some point that we figure it out. But usually it's too late. [28:12] Marty Bent: Sup, freaks? Listen, stacking Bitcoin doesn't mean making a big purchase every time you go to buy. Everybody's like, oh, I gotta get a whole Bitcoin, I gotta do this, I gotta do that. No, you don't. On Cash App, it can happen in the background of your everyday life. You turn on roundups, and as you're going and you're spending using the Cash App card, every purchase rounds up to the nearest dollar with spare change going into Bitcoin. You can also get paid in Bitcoin, so part of your paycheck stacks the moment it lands. You can set up direct deposits into Cash App. You can send Bitcoin to friends and family wherever they are. [29:05] Marty Bent: What's up, freaks? This episode was brought to you by Simple Mining. I'm sure many of you listening to this right now own Bitcoin and own it the same way. You go on an exchange, you buy it, sweep it to the cold storage, maybe you keep it on the exchange and you pay full price. But there's a smaller group of business owners, family offices, and investors with sharp CPAs that are quietly getting theirs a different way. They own the machines that make it. Here's how it works. You buy the miners at Simple Mining. Simple Mining hosts them, runs them at their facilities in Iowa on industrial power rates you could never get on your own. Bitcoin they mine goes straight from your machine to your wallet. 2 reasons I find this interesting right now. [29:37] Marty Bent: The second one is the one that nobody's talking about. One is the economics, cheap power. This lets you convert your electricity into Bitcoin at a discount to spot. You're acquiring the asset below the sticker price everyone else pays. 2, and listen closely, if you've had a big income year, making a lot of money out there, I know a lot of you freaks are making a lot of money. Miners are classified as computer equipment with the big beautiful bill. Equipment means depreciation. Qualifying buyers can write off the entire purchase in year one, It's the same playbook real estate investors have run for decades pointed at Bitcoin. [31:13] Théo Mogenet: Yeah, this is a really important part of the picture because the public debt is usually what financial commentators focus on, but it can only be serviced with a real thriving economy. And the extent to which you will be able to wiggle your way out of an overindebted problem depends largely on the debt burden that is carried by the private sector, the private non-financial sector, I should say. So basically the real economy. And in the US, for example, you don't have that much non-financial private sector debt. It's the same in the UK. I would point out other countries that have a way bigger problem, such as France, for example, Because there the private debt is way higher in points of GDP. [37:00] Marty Bent: Yeah. I'm trying to find the quote that you— I forget if it was in the manifesto or the piece on France, but I think, I mean, basically, it's not verbatim, but essentially like the young are going to take the burden of the cost on all this. They're going to pay for the old. [37:23] Théo Mogenet: Yeah. So I think the he who pays last pays most. [37:31] Marty Bent: Yes, that's what it is. He who pays last pays most. And so I think this is a good time to transition and zoom in on France, where you talked about the ongoing protests and how the sort of animus behind them is misdirected and the people participating in them, if they are earnestly rioting against high the cost of education don't understand the problem. And you start with a history lesson again on the phrase laissez-nous faire, going back to 1681 where Jean-Baptiste Colbert met with French merchants and counterparties in Britain and in the Netherlands and created this or breathed this line. Into existence. So what's what's the back the historical backdrop and how does it connect with what's currently happening in France? [38:31] Théo Mogenet: So yeah, this was during so at the end of the 17th century during the reign of Louis XIV, which is famous for Versailles, for like the big French culture, big state expenditure, and also for waging war against a lot of European powers. And losing every one of them. So at the time, taxes increased, you had a lot of government intervention, and at the same time you had the beginning of, we would say, a liberal institution forming both in the UK and in the United Province, which is now the Netherlands. And so French merchants and French manufacturing base were outcompeted by the British and Dutch one. [49:14] Marty Bent: All right, freaks, you know I don't take sponsored money from products I wouldn't use myself. So listen up. The Aave and Bitcoin Visa card is one of the most interesting things I've seen in the Bitcoin lending space in a long time. Here's the deal. You can get a line of credit up to $1 million backed by your Bitcoin without selling a single sat. No games, no annual fees, no minimum draws, and your Bitcoin is custodied by BitGo, one of the most trusted names in digital asset security. Aven never lends it out. There's no rehypothecation. You stay in control. You can lock in a fixed rate for up to 10 years. [51:37] Marty Bent: It's insane. 3% of GDP is the public spending. 6% of GDP is raised from compulsory levies. 1% of GDP. I mean, the public debt, 190% of GDP, that's getting to almost the point of no return that many people like to cite, which is 120%. 14%. And GDP growth going negative in Q1 of this year and being flat in Q2. I mean, this highlights right here that option number one, you can't grow your way out of this. It's not happening. It's obviously not manifesting in France. And to your point about Germany sort of footing the bill, or the more productive economies in the eurozone that use the euro currency footing the bill for the countries that, that trend towards socialism and welfare, that's not going to persist. [53:06] Théo Mogenet: Yeah, and there's an interesting game theoretic implication with this, which is also that we have some assets that Germany needs in some sense. So we are the only real nuclear power within the European Union, and because they are quite afraid of the Germans and the— not the Germans, the Russians and and the war in Ukraine escalating in something in which Europe is dragged on, if we had some political leaders with balls, we could also basically fold their hand and leverage these geopolitical assets to get some debt restructuring. Because a large part of this debt, as we mentioned, is also held by the German Bundesbank or by German financial institutions. [56:57] Marty Bent: Yeah. And you end the piece with a paragraph I'm going to read now. In Choose's views, Victor Hugo wrote, Providence has willed that there has always been something great at the head of France. Under the Old Regime, it was a king. Under the Empire, a man. Under the Republican Assembly— an avid student of history, the French writer knew all too well his country's unique tendency to collapse and then come back from nowhere. Perhaps it's going to be yet another time, but this time Providence would have to put something greater still at its head: freedom. And do you have any hope that this can happen in France? This is the cultural sort of fortitude of the French people strong enough to collapse yet again and rise from the ashes? [57:39] Théo Mogenet: I actually do, and for another reason, which is that since its formation as a nation, France has been a country built upon ideas. So the country was first created at the end of the 5th century, so it's one of the oldest A country in Europe, actually, when this Frank lord called Clovis actually converted to Catholicism on the back of the fall of the Roman Empire and had a big victory against all his enemies and decided that, okay, it means that God is on my side. It's a sign of providence. And so now I will create this Rome. under the tutelage and the patronage of the Roman Catholic Church. [1:04:27] Marty Bent: Well, I'm hoping and praying that France fixes it. So you guys figure it out because I don't take any offense to you saying you want the French in France working on mathematics and cryptography and all that. I think that's what any people should want. I certainly want that for Americans. You should want that for the French people. But I mean, we're an hour in. We haven't even brought up Bitcoin. Bitcoin. It's been mentioned a couple of times, but to your point, like freedom may be the sort of tingle of providence needed in France to reemerge stronger than it is now. And I think Bitcoin could play a big role into that. [1:05:39] Théo Mogenet: And it's a funny thing because when Francis contacted me, Because he successfully exported Bull Bitcoin in Costa Rica and then said to himself, oh, actually Bull Bitcoin doesn't need to be only a Canadian exchange. I can actually replicate what I've done in Canada in other countries. So he found me and then he told me about his plan to expand in Europe through France. My reaction was, are you crazy, mate? This is the worst country in the world. To be trying to get a license. We are crazy highly regulated. Even getting mica in France instead of another country is kind of a suicidal mission. But in the end, what we figured out is that once you get the license there, it's stronger than in any other country. [1:10:14] Marty Bent: Yeah. That's what I'm trying to figure out, whether it's France or over here in the United States from a political perspective. Is it hot as Hades or is it just warming up? Are we, are we in hell or are we still making our way down to the 7th, 7th layer of hell, as it may be? That's the big question. [1:10:39] Théo Mogenet: I think you have extremely good ingredients in the US. First, the history, the founding history of the country. A lot of people say there is nothing more American than Bitcoin. I would completely agree with that. I think also you have a lot of capital, a lot of attractiveness in your capital markets, a lot of pension savings and stuff like that, which we don't because of our socialist, I would even say communist pension system that we described before. And this will create a lot of Investments capabilities, and that's why I think the U.S. was home for Bitcoin really fast, and it makes total sense. Now, I'm wondering if in your country the the actual self-custody and the the the the willingness to break out from centralized and controlled payment system and banks, generally speaking, will pan out. That's something that you see, I think, from afar. In my opinion, you have this kind of back and forth within Bitcoin, but maybe it's just the cycles. I don't know. [1:11:56] Marty Bent: Yeah, I mean, it's been a trying 6 months for self-custody. I think the Coldcard RNG vulnerability and I think the fearmongering around AI vulnerabilities, which, I mean, maybe not fearmongering, maybe justified fear, because there is a ton of unknowns out there in terms of what's vulnerable. I mean, I think, was it yesterday somebody announced some random JavaScript library was injected to thousands of very popular websites that if you visited, like, you can— and you had private key material on your computer, which you shouldn't, but a lot of people do, could have swept wallets. It's tough, right? I think that's talking about like needing to go through hell to imagine what paradise can look like. Maybe that's what we're going through. Maybe that's like the idiosyncratic sort of existential crisis Bitcoin's going through right now. [1:12:53] Théo Mogenet: I think the whole internet is going through this crisis. Bitcoin was just hit first because it's a honeypot. Like, if I'm a hacker, I have more interest in targeting Bitcoin custodial system or self-custodial individuals or company. The good thing though, and I can vouch for that working at Bull, is that if you are agile enough, you can design new systems to address these new threats. Of course, it's a moving terrain, so it takes quite some time. There is also adaptation from individuals themselves. But I think sometimes we should also take into account, and I know it's difficult when you are not on the other side of this story, how much potential there is in this idea that non-engineers, like people like Francis, like me, can just take fucking clankers and prototype new Bitcoin products in the span of weeks. [1:14:44] Marty Bent: Yeah, and I said it a few weeks ago in Rabbit Hole Recap, but I want to reiterate now for anybody listening who's unaware. of the prowess of Bull Bitcoin. I think you guys are certainly, in my mind, without a doubt, the most cypherpunk company in the world. And again, really leaning into the last word of your most recent piece, which is freedom. I think the way in which you've designed not only the company, but the product suite is to ensure that your users have the utmost freedom possible. Like starting out with, you can't hold Bitcoin on Bull Bitcoin, you need to send it to self-custody. [1:16:00] Théo Mogenet: Well, most of the credit is due to Francis, honestly. And it's extremely interesting because he was trained in political science initially, and I'm more trained in mathematics and business. And when I arrived, I noticed directly that the guy actually intuitively nailed the hierarchy of things that an entrepreneur should do. The way I described it to external people is that at Bull Bitcoin, everything is downstream of value because he's really inspired by a mission of having Bitcoin succeed. In its cypherpunk ethos, every decision he makes in every dimension, being product design, fundraising that he never did to maintain its independence, how he decided to spend capital, how he decided to allocate capital, I should say, all these things, even marketing, it's always downstream of values. [1:18:18] Marty Bent: Low time preference. Theo? This has been incredible, incredible catch-up. Took way too long to catch up, but I'm happy that, uh, we did to talk about the, the, not only the blog series that you guys have launched and will continue to produce moving forward, but just to catch up and generally talk shop. It's always a pleasure, sir. [1:18:41] Théo Mogenet: Likewise. Thanks for having me. [1:18:44] Marty Bent: All right. That's all we got today, freaks. Peace and love. Hey there. Thank you for watching the whole video. If you made it this far, I imagine you got some value out of it. If you wouldn't mind liking and subscribing and maybe sharing with friends and family, it helps us out here at TFTC immensely. And then beyond that, we have a very valuable newsletter called The Commoner. io and subscribe to that. We cover Bitcoin, AI, energy markets, macro, political, cultural discussions. We've been running it for a decade. Highly recommend you sign up for that to stay up to date with what we're covering beyond these conversations.